Gusto vs. OnPay: Payroll Software Compared
Disclosure: SoBizee may earn compensation when you click a paid link, submit a qualifying inquiry or make a purchase through links on this page. Commercial relationships do not determine our editorial evaluations or recommendations. Read our Advertising & Affiliate Disclosure.
Comparison at a Glance
| Criterion | ||
|---|---|---|
| Fit | Small businesses that want tiered plans, optional benefits, and time tracking and HR tools from one provider. | Small businesses that want one payroll fee and prefer to add HR, time tracking and support as separate items. |
| Entry price | Published; see Gusto’s pricing page. Simple covers one state; multi-state requires Plus or Premium. Billed month to month. | OnPay publishes its price as a base fee plus a per-worker fee; see OnPay’s pricing page. OnPay bills monthly and counts each worker included in a pay run in the prior billing period, even if their net pay was zero. Each worker is counted once per billing period. |
| Free plan or trial | No free plan or trial stated for base plans. A trial is listed for the Time and Attendance Plus add-on only. | No free plan stated. A separate free trial was not confirmed. |
| Decisive features and limits | Plus adds time tracking, unlimited next-day pay and multi-state payroll. Premium adds same-day and instant pay, HR guidance and Business Compliance. Instant and same-day pay carry per-payroll fees (amounts in the Gusto review). Human support weekdays 6 AM to 6 PM Mountain; help center 24/7. | One payroll plan. HR, Time Tracking, Compliance Resources and Live HR Support are priced as separate add-ons (amounts in the OnPay review). Free setup and migration stated. Support hours not stated. |
| Payroll tax filing | Files and pays taxes each payroll, with W-2 and 1099 filing included. Says it offers payroll in all 50 states. Simple covers one state and multi-state payroll requires Plus or Premium; state tax registration is priced separately. | Lists federal, state and local filings, W-2 and 1099 forms, and payroll in all 50 states at no extra cost (OnPay’s statements). |
| Review & Visit Site |
Both prices are a monthly base plus a per-person fee. Total cost will differ with what you add: Gusto’s higher tiers and paid add-ons, and OnPay’s separately priced HR, time tracking and support. SoBizee’s sources do not confirm that Gusto’s “person” and OnPay’s “worker” count contractors the same way, and Gusto’s pricing page displays a dollar sign without naming the currency.
Choose Gusto if you want published tiers where higher plans add time tracking and faster pay. Gusto publishes its plan prices. Simple is Gusto’s starting plan for employer payroll and covers one state, billed month to month; multi-state payroll requires Plus or Premium. See Gusto’s pricing page for current prices. The tradeoff most likely to change the choice: human support is weekdays, 6 AM to 6 PM Mountain time, and faster pay, support and compliance tools sit in higher tiers or paid add-ons.
Choose OnPay if you want one payroll plan with HR, time tracking and support priced as separate add-ons. OnPay publishes its price as a base fee plus a per-worker fee; see OnPay’s pricing page. OnPay states US-based phone, chat and email support. The tradeoffs most likely to change the choice: OnPay’s support hours and size range are not stated.
SoBizee’s Verdict
SoBizee does not name a winner. Shortlist Gusto if tiered plans with time tracking and faster pay appeal to you and weekday daytime support in Mountain time works for your team. Shortlist OnPay if you want one payroll fee with HR, time tracking and support priced separately. Price the exact modules you need at your own headcount before you choose. If you need a quote-based package or a PEO, the Payroll Software and Services buyer’s guide lists other options to compare.
Keep Reading
Read the full reviews: Gusto review | OnPay review
Compare more products: Payroll Software and Services buyer’s guide
Sources and Verification
Research basis: Gusto’s first-party pages were read. OnPay’s homepage was read, and its retail pricing page was also read. Prices are as displayed on those pages and are not current guarantees; confirm current details with Gusto and OnPay before you buy.
Sources: SoBizee’s product research for both products and SoBizee’s Gusto and OnPay reviews, which rest on each company’s own pages. Statements about features, support and pricing are information displayed by each company and were not independently verified. Security and compliance detail is in the linked reviews.
Open questions: Gusto’s currency, local tax handling, human support channels and the “Complete plan” reference. OnPay’s accuracy guarantee terms, size range, named integrations, support hours and garnishment support.