SoBizee

Gusto vs. QuickBooks Payroll: Payroll Software Compared

  • Published 2026-11-19
  • Last verified 2026-10-13
Research & update details
  • Research date 2026-10-12
  • Next review 2027-03-12

Disclosure: SoBizee may earn compensation when you click a paid link, submit a qualifying inquiry or make a purchase through links on this page. Commercial relationships do not determine our editorial evaluations or recommendations. Read our Advertising & Affiliate Disclosure.

This comparison covers payroll only. QuickBooks Online accounting is not covered.

Comparison at a Glance

CriterionGustoQuickBooks Payroll
FitBusinesses that want payroll-first software with published plans and optional benefits and HR add-ons.Businesses that keep their books in QuickBooks and are ready to confirm plan name and price on Intuit’s current screens.
Entry pricePublished; see Gusto’s pricing page. Simple covers one state; multi-state requires Plus or Premium. Billed month to month.Intuit’s pages conflict on plan names, the base price and the per-employee fee, so ask Intuit for the standard applicable rate and plan. A “Core” reference has no matching plan. QuickBooks Online bundle prices are outside this comparison.
Free plan or trialNo free plan or trial stated for base plans.No free plan stated. A 30-day trial is described on the payroll-only page but not the bundle page, and its terms were not available.
Decisive features and limitsHigher tiers add time tracking, multi-state payroll and faster pay; instant and same-day pay carry per-payroll fees (amounts in the Gusto review). A long list of integrations, including Xero and QuickBooks. Human support weekdays 6 AM to 6 PM Mountain.Direct QuickBooks sync is stated; non-Intuit integrations were not stated on the pages reviewed. Full-service tax filing and unlimited 1099 e-filing are stated. Phone and chat access to payroll experts is advertised; hours for existing customers are not stated. Whether QuickBooks Online is required is unconfirmed.
Review & Visit Site

These entry prices are not directly comparable: Intuit’s own pages conflict on QuickBooks Payroll’s plan names, base price and per-employee fee, and Gusto’s pricing page displays a dollar sign without naming the currency. SoBizee does not state which product costs less.

Choose Gusto if you want a payroll-first product with one published plan table and a long integration list. Gusto publishes its plan prices. Simple is Gusto’s starting plan for employer payroll and covers one state, billed month to month; multi-state payroll requires Plus or Premium. See Gusto’s pricing page for current prices. The tradeoff most likely to change the choice: human support is weekdays, 6 AM to 6 PM Mountain time, and no free trial is stated for base plans.

Choose QuickBooks Payroll if your books are in QuickBooks and direct sync is a priority. The tradeoffs most likely to change the choice: Intuit’s pages conflict on QuickBooks Payroll’s plan names, base price and per-employee fee, and whether QuickBooks Online is required to buy it is unconfirmed.

SoBizee’s Verdict

SoBizee does not name a winner. The decision is mostly about where you keep your accounting data. Shortlist Gusto if you want published plan prices and a long integration list. Shortlist QuickBooks Payroll if QuickBooks is your accounting system and you will confirm the plan name, base price and per-employee fee on Intuit’s current checkout or quote screen before comparing totals at your headcount. If you need one clean published price before checkout, the Payroll Software and Services buyer’s guide lists other options to compare.

Keep Reading

Read the full reviews: Gusto review | QuickBooks Payroll review

Compare more products: Payroll Software and Services buyer’s guide

Sources and Verification

Research basis: Gusto’s first-party pages were read. QuickBooks Payroll’s were read and reverified. Prices are as displayed on those pages and are not current guarantees; confirm current details with Gusto and Intuit before you buy.

Sources: SoBizee’s product research for both products and SoBizee’s Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll reviews, which rest on each company’s own pages. Statements about features, support and pricing are information displayed by each company and were not independently verified. Security and compliance detail is in the linked reviews.

Open questions: Intuit’s current plan names, base price and per-employee fee; whether QuickBooks Online is required; trial terms; non-Intuit integrations; support hours for existing customers. Gusto’s currency, next-day pay per-person figure, global contractor charge scope and “Complete plan” reference.