SoBizee

OnPay vs. Patriot Payroll: Payroll Software Compared

  • Published 2026-11-19
  • Last verified 2026-10-13
Research & update details
  • Research date 2026-10-12
  • Next review 2027-03-12

Disclosure: SoBizee may earn compensation when you click a paid link, submit a qualifying inquiry or make a purchase through links on this page. Commercial relationships do not determine our editorial evaluations or recommendations. Read our Advertising & Affiliate Disclosure.

This comparison covers OnPay and Patriot Payroll for very small businesses that want published pricing. Patriot Accounting is not covered. Published pricing is not a claim that either product costs less than the other.

Comparison at a Glance

CriterionOnPayPatriot Payroll
FitSmall businesses that want one payroll plan and the option to add HR, time tracking and support.Small US businesses with straightforward payroll, all employees in the US and no need for garnishment or child support handling.
Entry pricePayroll Essentials: a monthly base price plus a per-worker price. Bundles and add-ons are priced separately.Basic Payroll and Full Service Payroll: each is a monthly base price plus a per-worker price, billed monthly in arrears.
Free plan or trialNo free plan stated. A separate free trial was not confirmed. Free setup and migration stated.No free plan stated. Free assisted setup stated.
Decisive features and limitsOne payroll plan; HR, Time Tracking, Compliance Resources and Live HR Support are priced as separate add-ons (see the OnPay review). No employee limit stated. Garnishment support not stated. US-based phone, chat and email support; hours not stated.1 to 500 employees, located in the US. Patriot says it does not handle garnishments, child support or Form 943 and requires a business bank account. Time & Attendance and HR are add-ons. An additional state is priced per month per state on Full Service. Free US-based phone support; hours not stated.
Payroll tax filingLists federal, state and local filings and W-2 and 1099 forms (OnPay’s statements). Accuracy is described as guaranteed; terms were not visible.Full Service files federal, state and most local taxes and year-end forms at no extra charge, per Patriot. A nominal 1099 e-filing fee applies on Basic; the amount is unverified.
Review & Visit Site

Both products charge a monthly base fee plus a per-worker fee. OnPay counts workers included in a pay run in the prior billing period, even if their net pay was zero. Patriot counts employees and contractors it says you paid at least once during the month. Compare the plans and add-ons you need using each vendor’s worker-count rule.

Choose OnPay if you want one payroll plan with add-ons you pick, free setup and migration, and no employee limit stated on the pages reviewed. Payroll Essentials is priced as a monthly base plus a per-worker amount. The billing detail most likely to affect your estimate: OnPay counts each worker included in a pay run in the prior billing period, even if their net pay was zero.

Choose Patriot Payroll if you are a small business with all employees located in the US and straightforward payroll needs. The tradeoffs most likely to change the choice: Patriot states a limit of 1 to 500 employees and says it does not handle garnishments, child support or Form 943.

SoBizee’s Verdict

SoBizee does not name a winner. Both publish prices before any sales contact, in different shapes. Shortlist OnPay if you want one payroll plan with add-ons and no stated employee limit. Shortlist Patriot Payroll if you are a small US business, your employees are all in the US and you do not need garnishment or child support handling. If you need garnishment support or have employees outside the US, the Payroll Software and Services buyer’s guide lists other options to compare.

Keep Reading

Read the full reviews: OnPay review | Patriot Payroll review

Compare more products: Payroll Software and Services buyer’s guide

Sources and Verification

Research basis: OnPay’s first-party pages were read. Patriot Payroll’s were read. Prices are as displayed on those pages and are not current guarantees; confirm current details with OnPay and Patriot Payroll before you buy.

Sources: SoBizee’s product research for both products and SoBizee’s OnPay and Patriot Payroll reviews, which rest on each company’s own pages. Statements about features, support and pricing are information displayed by each company and were not independently verified. Security and compliance detail is in the linked reviews.

Open questions: OnPay’s accuracy guarantee terms, size limits, named integrations and garnishment support. Patriot’s 1099 e-filing fee amount and guarantee terms.