Gusto vs. ADP RUN: Payroll Software Compared
Disclosure: SoBizee may earn compensation when you click a paid link, submit a qualifying inquiry or make a purchase through links on this page. Commercial relationships do not determine our editorial evaluations or recommendations. Read our Advertising & Affiliate Disclosure.
This comparison covers Gusto payroll and RUN Powered by ADP only. ADP Workforce Now is not covered.
Comparison at a Glance
| Criterion | ||
|---|---|---|
| Fit | Small businesses that want to model cost from published plans before contacting sales. | Businesses of 1 to 49 employees (as ADP states) that want a quote-based, service-led relationship. |
| Entry price | Published; see Gusto’s pricing page. Simple covers one state; multi-state requires Plus or Premium. Billed month to month. | No price published; quote only. Contract terms not stated on the pages reviewed. |
| Free plan or trial | No free plan or trial stated for base plans. | No free plan or trial described. |
| Decisive features and limits | Three tiers; unlimited payroll runs stated. Time tracking from Plus; same-day and instant pay in Premium. Time and Attendance Plus, benefits and compliance items are paid add-ons. Human support weekdays 6 AM to 6 PM Mountain. | RUN is for 1 to 49 employees per ADP. Phone and chat listed as 24/7 on all packages. HR content appears in the higher packages; Time & Attendance, Retirement, Workers’ Compensation and Health Insurance are add-ons without prices. SoBizee’s research is inconsistent on which package includes some HR features, so no package-by-package list is given. |
| Payroll tax filing | Files payroll taxes; W-2 and 1099 filing included. | ADP states it calculates, files, deposits and reconciles taxes and pays fines and penalties from its own filing errors (terms not reviewed). W-2 and 1099 filing carries an additional fee with no amount shown. |
| Review & Visit Site |
ADP does not publish a RUN price, so request an itemized written quote that names the package, tax-form fees and add-ons before comparing totals with Gusto’s published figures.
Choose Gusto if you want to see a monthly cost structure before talking to anyone. Gusto publishes its plan prices. Simple is Gusto’s starting plan for employer payroll and covers one state; multi-state payroll requires Plus or Premium. Billed month to month. See Gusto’s pricing page for current prices. The tradeoff most likely to change the choice: human support is weekdays, 6 AM to 6 PM Mountain time, with a 24/7 help center, and Gusto states no employee range (“all sizes of business”).
Choose ADP RUN if you prefer a quote-based, service-led process and have 49 or fewer employees. ADP lists phone and chat support as 24/7 on all RUN packages. The tradeoffs most likely to change the choice: ADP does not publish a RUN price and lists W-2 and 1099 filing for an additional fee with no amount shown.
SoBizee’s Verdict
SoBizee does not name a winner. The main difference is how each is bought. Shortlist Gusto if you want to see pricing before a sales conversation and can work with weekday support hours. Shortlist ADP RUN if you prefer a quote-based process, have 49 or fewer employees and value phone and chat listed as 24/7. If you expect to pass 49 employees, ask ADP about the path beyond RUN. If you need a published price to budget from, the Payroll Software and Services buyer’s guide lists other options to compare.
Keep Reading
Read the full reviews: Gusto review | ADP RUN review
Compare more products: Payroll Software and Services buyer’s guide
Sources and Verification
Research basis: Gusto’s first-party pages were read. ADP RUN’s were read. Prices are as displayed on those dates and are not current guarantees; confirm current details with Gusto and ADP before you buy.
Sources: SoBizee’s product research for both products and SoBizee’s Gusto and ADP RUN reviews, which rest on each company’s own pages. Statements about features, support and pricing are information displayed by each company and were not independently verified. Security and compliance detail is in the linked reviews.
Open questions: Gusto’s currency, next-day pay per-person figure, global contractor charge scope and “Complete plan” reference. ADP’s Bill Pay and Client Invoicing fee status, package feature placement, W-2 and 1099 fee amount, RUN API and guarantee terms.