Payroll Software and Services Buyer’s Guide 2026
Disclosure: SoBizee may earn compensation when you click a paid link, submit a qualifying inquiry or make a purchase through links on this page. Commercial relationships do not determine our editorial evaluations or recommendations. Read our Advertising & Affiliate Disclosure.
What Is Payroll Software?
Payroll software helps employers calculate pay, withhold taxes and produce pay stubs and year-end forms. Owners and finance teams use it to pay employees on time and keep payroll records; some services also file and pay payroll taxes on the employer’s behalf. Payroll buying decisions usually turn on four questions: whether you want published prices or are comfortable with a sales-led quote; whether you need payroll alone or payroll tied to HR, time and benefits; how many states and worker types you pay; and whether you actually want a payroll product or a PEO (a different employment arrangement). There is no single right choice. The right product depends on headcount, states, worker types, how much HR you want in the same system, and how you want to buy. Use the fit guidance below, then confirm current pricing and terms with the provider, because pricing and packaging change frequently.
Our Top Payroll Picks
Three picks for different business needs, in no ranked order.

Gusto
Best For Very small businesses that want published pricing
Pros: Published plan prices with a per-person structure and month-to-month terms; Unlimited payroll runs on every plan, with full-service payroll in all 50 states (multi-state payroll on Plus and Premium).
Cons: Simple covers one state only, and per-person fees rise with each plan tier; next-day, same-day and instant pay, Priority Support, Business Compliance and HR and compliance tools are add-ons or plan-gated.

Rippling
Best For Payroll that draws on HR data in one platform
Pros: Payroll draws on HR data held in the same platform, which reduces duplicate entry for buyers adopting multiple modules.
Cons: No published price; buyers must request a quote; The core platform is required, so payroll cannot be bought as a standalone product; Free trial status is contradictory across Rippling’s pages.

Justworks
Best For Deciding between payroll software and a PEO
Pros: Published pricing for Payroll, PEO and add-ons; Offers both payroll-only and PEO paths, so buyers can move between them within one vendor; International contractor payments are offered as an add-on.
Cons: The three models are priced very differently, and the PEO employment arrangement is not explained on the vendor pages reviewed; No third-party attestation (such as SOC 2) was stated on the security page reviewed.
Compare Payroll Software and Services at a Glance
Compare best fit, starting prices and key features to build your shortlist. Check whether pricing covers payroll alone or includes a broader HR or PEO service.
| Product | Best For | Price | Standout Strength | Key Features | Review / Visit Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() Gusto | Very small and growing small businesses that want published prices they can model themselves. | From $49 per month plus $6 per person per month (Simple, one state; multi-state requires Plus) | Month-to-month plans with unlimited payroll runs on every tier and full-service payroll in all 50 states, with multi-state payroll on Plus and Premium (vendor statements). | Files and pays payroll taxes each run; W-2 and 1099 filing included; optional HR, benefits and Time and Attendance add-ons; next-day pay on Plus and Premium and Instant Pay in Premium; about 153 listed integrations (vendor-listed). No trial stated for base plans. Human support is weekday daytime Mountain time. Simple covers one state; Plus and Premium add multi-state payroll. State tax registration is priced separately. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() ADP RUN | Growing small businesses comfortable with a sales-led quote; ADP positions RUN for 1 to 49 employees. | See vendor pricing | ADP-performed tax calculation, filing, deposit and reconciliation, with 24/7 phone or chat support on all four packages (vendor statements). | Four packages from payroll-only up to payroll with HR tools; garnishment payment service on Enhanced and above (ADP pages are inconsistent, confirm tier contents); optional Time and Attendance, Retirement, Workers’ Compensation and Health Insurance add-ons; W-2 and 1099 forms carry an additional fee. RUN only, not Workforce Now; positioned for 1 to 49 employees. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() Paychex Flex | Growing small businesses comfortable with a sales-led quote. | See vendor pricing | Automated multistate tax calculation and remittance, with phone, chat and online support on all plans (vendor statements). | Four named packages (the pages reviewed do not map features to packages); named accounting integrations include Intuit QuickBooks, Sage Intacct, Xero, Oracle NetSuite and Jirav; HR, time and benefits modules sold separately; Developer Center APIs described, access terms not stated. Payroll primarily designed for US-based employees and contractors. PEO and insurance out of scope. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() QuickBooks Payroll | Businesses already running QuickBooks; published prices should be treated with caution. | See vendor pricing (Intuit’s pages conflict) | Direct connection to QuickBooks accounting, with full-service tax filing (vendor statements). | Unlimited 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC e-filing. Next-day or same-day direct deposit is listed for select bundles; confirm availability for your plan with Intuit. Premium adds HR tools and a setup review, Elite adds full setup and HR workflows. Intuit’s pages conflict on plan names, and whether QuickBooks Online is required for payroll-only plans is unconfirmed. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() Rippling | Businesses considering a broader HCM platform that are comfortable with a sales-led quote. | See vendor pricing | Payroll draws on HR data in the same platform; the core platform is required (vendor description). | Automatic multi-agency tax filing and unlimited pay runs advertised; global payroll and contractor payments claimed, countries not stated; names Xero, QuickBooks and NetSuite for payroll accounting integrations. Free trial status is contradictory across Rippling pages (the pricing page states none; the payroll page shows ‘Create free account’); confirm with Rippling. Payroll module only, not the wider HCM, IT or spend platform. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() Paycom | Businesses considering a broader HCM platform that are comfortable with a sales-led quote. | See vendor pricing | Employee-driven payroll entry with error checking, delivered inside Paycom’s single-database HCM platform (vendor descriptions). | Tax, garnishment and filing handling including Forms 941 and 940; single point of contact for implementation; general ledger integration tool (GL Concierge). Paycom states it does not integrate specifically with other providers, although it builds custom converters to import data. Packaging for payroll alone should be confirmed. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() Paylocity | Growing small businesses, and buyers considering a broader HCM platform, who are comfortable with a sales-led quote. | See vendor pricing | Separate small-business (1 to 99), midsize (100 to 499) and enterprise (500+) offerings, with open APIs advertised (vendor statements). | Garnishment Managed Services listed; global payroll claimed in “100+ countries” (scope not stated); optional HR and talent tools; three-phase switching guide. Feature-by-tier mapping is unclear. No trial stated. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() OnPay | Very small and growing small businesses that want published prices. | From $49 per month plus $6 per worker per month (Payroll Essentials) | Simple published structure of a base plan plus a per-worker fee; payroll in all 50 states and unlimited pay runs at no extra cost (vendor claim). | Federal, state and local filings listed; optional HR, Time Tracking, Compliance Resources and Live HR Support add-ons; free setup and migration stated; US-based phone, chat and email support. No trial stated. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() Patriot Payroll | Very small businesses that want low published entry prices and have US-located employees. | From $17 per month plus $4 per worker paid (Basic Payroll, billed monthly in arrears) | Free US-based phone support and assisted setup, with published add-on pricing (vendor statements). | Full Service Payroll files federal, state and most local taxes and year-end forms; Time and Attendance and HR add-ons; QuickBooks Online sync. Does not handle garnishments, child support or Form 943. Employees must be located in the US; stated range 1 to 500 employees. Patriot Payroll only, not Patriot Accounting. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
![]() Justworks | Very small businesses looking at Justworks Payroll. The PEO is a separate purchase decision, not a like-for-like alternative. | Payroll: from $50 per month plus $8 per employee per month (PEO priced separately; see vendor pricing) | The only product in this set sold both as a payroll product and as a PEO, as separate purchase models. | Payroll: multistate payroll, PTO tracking, document center and accounting integrations advertised; international contractor add-on (60+ countries); no implementation fee claimed. PEO provides benefits access; the PEO co-employment arrangement is not explained on the pages reviewed. Justworks describes its payroll for small businesses; SoBizee did not find an employee-count range on the pages reviewed. | Read ReviewVisit Site |
Starting prices show the lowest paid plan we could establish, with the billing basis where applicable. “See vendor pricing” means a usable starting price wasn’t established. Confirm current terms with the vendor.
Quick Picks by Buyer Fit
All fit guidance in this section is SoBizee editorial analysis, drawn from the documented information in the reviews. It is not a ranking. Products are listed in the set order within each use case, not by preference. Affiliate or referral availability played no part in these groupings.
- Very small businesses: Gusto, OnPay, Patriot Payroll and Justworks (Payroll) publish entry prices with a base fee plus a per-person or per-worker structure, so a small team can model cost. Patriot Payroll states it does not handle garnishments, child support or Form 943 and requires US-located employees. Promotional prices (Patriot Payroll, OnPay, QuickBooks Payroll) may differ from long-run cost.
- Growing small businesses: Gusto, ADP RUN, Paychex Flex, Rippling, Paylocity and OnPay. Consider how pricing and packaging change as headcount grows. Gusto’s per-person fee rises with tier, ADP positions RUN for 1 to 49 employees and does not say whether growth past 49 requires a move, and Paychex Flex’s own size statements conflict.
- Buyers who want published pricing: Gusto, OnPay, Patriot Payroll and Justworks. QuickBooks Payroll also publishes prices, but Intuit’s pages conflict on plan names and the per-employee fee, so treat those figures with caution until Intuit confirms the current structure.
- Buyers comfortable with a sales-led quote: ADP RUN, Paychex Flex, Rippling, Paycom and Paylocity do not publish prices. ADP RUN and Paychex Flex pair the quote with phone or chat support across packages. Rippling, Paycom and Paylocity sit within broader platforms.
- Payroll plus HR tools: Gusto, ADP RUN (higher packages), OnPay, Patriot Payroll (HR add-on), Rippling, Paycom and Paylocity. HR tools are included, sold as add-ons, or part of a wider platform depending on the vendor.
- A broader HCM platform: Rippling, Paycom and Paylocity position payroll inside a broader platform. Rippling requires its core platform. Paycom states it does not integrate specifically with other providers, although it builds custom converters to import data. This may matter if you want to keep separate HR, time or accounting tools.
- Payroll versus a PEO: Justworks is the only product here sold both as payroll and as a PEO. A PEO is a different employment arrangement and not a like-for-like price comparison with payroll-only products.
- Already running QuickBooks: QuickBooks Payroll’s main stated advantage is a direct connection to QuickBooks accounting. Confirm the plan structure and whether a QuickBooks Online subscription is required.
Product Summaries

Gusto
Best for Very small and growing small businesses that want published prices they can model themselves.
What it does: Gusto states it files and pays taxes each payroll, says it offers payroll in all 50 states, and includes W-2 and 1099 filing. Simple covers one state and multi-state payroll requires Plus or Premium; state tax registration is priced separately.
Reasons to consider it: Unlimited payroll runs on every plan (vendor claim); about 153 listed integrations; SOC 1 and SOC 2 reports stated, available after an NDA.
Important limitations: Simple covers one state only, and per-person fees rise with each tier. Next-day, same-day and instant pay and Priority Support are add-ons or plan-gated. Local tax handling is not stated on the payroll page.
Pricing snapshot: Month-to-month. Simple, Gusto’s starting plan for employer payroll, from $49 per month plus $6 per person per month, for payroll in one state; multi-state payroll requires Plus or Premium. State tax registration is priced separately. No trial stated for base plans.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Small teams that want to model cost from published prices.

ADP RUN
Best for Growing small businesses comfortable with a sales-led quote; ADP positions RUN for 1 to 49 employees.
What it does: Covers RUN Powered by ADP only, not Workforce Now. Four packages; ADP states it calculates, files, deposits and reconciles payroll taxes.
Reasons to consider it: 24/7 phone or online chat support on all four packages. ADP states it pays fines or penalties from its own tax filing errors (terms not reviewed).
Important limitations: W-2 and 1099 forms carry an additional fee, amount not stated. ADP’s pages conflicted on some package contents, so confirm each tier.
Pricing snapshot: No published price on the pages reviewed; ask ADP for a quote. No free trial described.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Employers under 50 who accept a sales conversation and want phone or chat support.

Paychex Flex
Best for Growing small businesses comfortable with a sales-led quote.
What it does: Paychex Flex payroll only; Paychex PEO and insurance are out of scope. Four named packages. Paychex states it automatically calculates, files and pays payroll taxes for every state where employees work.
Reasons to consider it: Phone, chat and online support on all plans. Named accounting integrations include Intuit QuickBooks, Sage Intacct, Xero, Oracle NetSuite and Jirav.
Important limitations: The pages reviewed do not map features to packages or explain add-on pricing. Paychex’s own employee-size ranges conflict. Payroll is primarily designed for US-based employees and contractors.
Pricing snapshot: No published price on the pages SoBizee reviewed. SoBizee did not find a free trial on those pages; ask Paychex whether one is offered.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Small to larger employers that want a quote-based service; confirm packages, add-on costs and size range directly.

QuickBooks Payroll
Best for Businesses already running QuickBooks; published prices should be treated with caution.
What it does: Payroll only; QuickBooks Online accounting is separate. Connects directly to QuickBooks accounting and advertises full-service tax filing and unlimited 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC e-filing.
Reasons to consider it: Direct accounting connection is its main stated advantage. Premium includes HR tools and a setup review; Elite includes full setup.
Important limitations: Intuit’s pages conflict on plan names and the entry per-employee fee. Whether QuickBooks Online is required for payroll-only plans is unconfirmed.
Pricing snapshot: See vendor pricing. Intuit’s pages conflict on plan names and the per-employee fee. A 30-day trial is mentioned on one page; terms unavailable.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): QuickBooks users; confirm the current plan structure first.

Rippling
Best for Businesses considering a broader HCM platform that are comfortable with a sales-led quote.
What it does: Covers the payroll module only; the core platform is required. Payroll draws on HR data in the same platform. Rippling claims automatic tax filing with federal, state and local agencies and unlimited pay runs.
Reasons to consider it: Names Xero, QuickBooks and NetSuite for payroll accounting integrations.
Important limitations: Free trial status is contradictory across pages. Implementation and support details are not stated. State coverage is not stated. Vendor-stated security attestations describe the platform, not specifically the payroll module.
Pricing snapshot: No published price on the pages reviewed; custom quote. Modules are billed per employee per month, some with a monthly base fee, and the core platform is required. The pricing page states no free trial; the payroll page shows “Create free account.”
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Teams that want payroll inside one HR platform and accept buying the core platform.

Paycom
Best for Businesses considering a broader HCM platform that are comfortable with a sales-led quote.
What it does: Payroll-first, delivered within Paycom’s single-database HCM platform alongside time and HR. Vendor descriptions cite employee-driven payroll entry with error checking, and tax, garnishment and filing handling.
Reasons to consider it: Three-step implementation with a single point of contact. Security page lists ISO 27001, SAML 2.0 single sign-on and two-step verification.
Important limitations: Paycom states it does not integrate specifically with other providers, although it builds custom converters to import data, which may matter if you keep separate tools. The SOC 2 report type is not stated. Packaging for payroll alone should be confirmed.
Pricing snapshot: No published pricing on the pages reviewed, which show “Get started” and “Request meeting” options; they do not explicitly say pricing is quote-only. Trial not stated. Reviewed.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Employers willing to move more functions onto one platform.

Paylocity
Best for Growing small businesses, and buyers considering a broader HCM platform, who are comfortable with a sales-led quote.
What it does: Payroll-first within a broader HR platform. Offers separate segments: small business 1 to 99, midsize 100 to 499, enterprise 500+. Lists Garnishment Managed Services.
Reasons to consider it: Open APIs advertised. Annual SOC 1 and SOC 2 Type II reports and ISO 27001:2022 are stated.
Important limitations: Feature-by-tier mapping is unclear. Support hours and channels for existing customers are not stated.
Pricing snapshot: No published pricing on the pages reviewed; sales-led. No trial stated. Reviewed.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Employers that may move between small, midsize and enterprise needs; confirm what each tier includes.

OnPay
Best for Very small and growing small businesses that want published prices.
What it does: Payroll with optional HR, time tracking and benefits; not described as a PEO. Lists federal, state and local filings, and states payroll in all 50 states and unlimited pay runs at no extra cost (vendor claim).
Reasons to consider it: Free setup and migration stated. US-based phone, chat and email support, with no paywall stated. SOC 2 Type II compliance stated.
Important limitations: Add-ons are priced separately. MFA is encouraged, not required, for client users. “Accuracy guaranteed” terms are not visible.
Pricing snapshot: Payroll Essentials $49 per month plus $6 per month per worker (the $55 retail headline reconciles for one worker). HR, Time Tracking and support are add-ons priced separately; no trial stated.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Small teams wanting a simple base-plus-per-worker structure; compare add-on costs like-for-like.

Patriot Payroll
Best for Very small businesses that want low published entry prices and have US-located employees.
What it does: Covers Patriot Payroll only, not Patriot Accounting. Full Service Payroll files federal, state and most local taxes and year-end forms. Stated size: 1 to 500 US-located employees.
Reasons to consider it: Free assisted setup and free US-based phone support stated. Add-on prices are published.
Important limitations: States it does not handle garnishments, child support or Form 943. Patriot’s pages show more than one price level for each plan; confirm which applies at checkout.
Pricing snapshot: Billed monthly in arrears. Basic Payroll from $17 per month plus $4 per worker paid; Full Service Payroll is priced higher. Confirm which price applies at checkout.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Very small US-only employers without garnishment needs; judge cost on original prices.

Justworks
Best for Very small businesses looking at Justworks Payroll. The PEO is a separate purchase decision, not a like-for-like alternative.
What it does: Sells a Payroll product and a PEO as separate models. Payroll lists multi-state payroll and PTO tracking. The PEO provides benefits access, including CHOICE and 401(k).
Reasons to consider it: Published prices for Payroll, PEO and add-ons. An international contractor add-on covers 60+ countries.
Important limitations: The pages reviewed do not explain the PEO co-employment arrangement. No SOC 2 or ISO attestation is stated on the security page reviewed. Justworks describes its payroll for small businesses; SoBizee did not find an employee-count range on the pages reviewed.
Pricing snapshot: Payroll from $50 per month plus $8 per employee per month. The PEO is priced separately per employee and is not comparable to payroll-only prices. Free trial not confirmed.
Who should consider it (editorial analysis): Small teams weighing Justworks Payroll against its own PEO; get written PEO terms first.
Compare Your Payroll Finalists
Choose two products to open SoBizee’s direct comparison, if one exists.
- Gusto vs. Justworks comparison
- Paycom vs. Paylocity comparison
- OnPay vs. Patriot Payroll comparison
- Gusto vs. QuickBooks Payroll comparison
- Gusto vs. Rippling comparison
- Gusto vs. ADP RUN comparison
- ADP RUN vs. Paychex Flex comparison
- Gusto vs. OnPay comparison
How to Choose Payroll Software or a Payroll Service
- Count your workers by type. Employees, US contractors and international contractors are priced and supported differently across these products.
- List the states where you pay people. Multistate handling, state registration and local tax handling are described differently by each vendor, and several vendors did not state local-tax coverage.
- Decide how you want to buy. Published pricing lets you model cost yourself. Quote-based products require a sales conversation before you can compare cost.
- Decide how much HR belongs in the same system. Payroll-only products are simpler. Platform products connect payroll to HR, time and benefits but may require buying the broader platform. Rippling requires its core platform, so payroll cannot be bought as a standalone product, and Paycom and Paylocity position payroll inside broader HCM platforms.
- Decide whether you need payroll software or a PEO. Justworks is the only product in this set that sells both a payroll product and a PEO. They are separate purchase decisions and should not be compared on price alone; see Payroll Software versus PEO versus Broader HCM Platform.
- Check pay speed and support. Direct deposit timing, same-day or instant pay, and support hours vary, and some are add-ons or plan-gated.
- Check what the vendor does not handle. Patriot Payroll states it does not handle garnishments, child support or Form 943, for example.
- Verify security evidence for the specific product. Company-level attestations do not always state which product they cover (see the “Security and Compliance Evidence” section).
- Get current pricing and terms in writing before committing.
HR, Time, Benefits and Add-On Considerations
Compare add-ons on a like-for-like basis. A product that appears inexpensive at the payroll layer may cost more once HR, time tracking, compliance support and faster pay are added, and a platform whose payroll price is unpublished may include HR capabilities that others sell separately. Ask each vendor for itemized pricing for the exact modules you need.
Security and Compliance Evidence
This section reports what each vendor states, at the scope it states it. Company-level statements are not converted into product-level conclusions, and absence from a page reviewed is not evidence of absence.
How to read this: SOC 1 relates to controls over financial reporting and SOC 2 to security-related trust criteria; Type I describes the design of controls at a point in time and Type II tests operating effectiveness over a period. Where a vendor does not state the type, scope or period, the claim cannot be fully evaluated. Ask vendors for the current SOC 2 report under NDA and confirm that the product you are buying is in its scope. SoBizee's reviews make no compliance claims beyond what each vendor states.
Pricing: Common Models in this Category
How the pricing models differ
- Base fee plus per-person fee (Gusto, OnPay, Patriot Payroll, Justworks Payroll, QuickBooks Payroll): total cost scales with headcount. The per-person unit is called "person," "worker," "employee" or "paid worker" depending on the vendor, and whether contractors count differs. Do not assume the same definition across vendors. Gusto's plans also differ by state coverage: Simple covers one state, and multi-state payroll requires Plus or Premium.
- Per-employee only (Justworks PEO): priced per employee, separately from Justworks Payroll. This is a PEO price and is not comparable to payroll-only prices; see vendor pricing.
- Quote-only or sales-led (ADP RUN, Paychex Flex, Rippling, Paycom, Paylocity): no public prices. For Rippling, modules are billed per employee per month and some carry a monthly base fee, and the core platform is required. ADP describes RUN as "tiered pricing." For Paycom, the pages reviewed did not explicitly say pricing is quote-only.
Published prices as shown on the research dates
OnPay's retail page headline reads "Pricing Starts at $55 Per Month," while its homepage says $49 plus $6 per worker; the retail calculator defaults to one paid worker, so the two reconcile. Patriot Payroll's pages show more than one price level for each plan, so confirm which price applies at checkout. Justworks sells Payroll and a PEO as separate models, and add-on pricing for contractors, time tracking and benefits is listed separately.
Material pricing conflicts and open items (preserved, not resolved)
- QuickBooks Payroll: Intuit's pages differ on plan names (bundle names versus Workforce Payroll, Premium and Elite, plus a "Core" reference with no Core plan listed) and on the entry per-employee fee. Whether QuickBooks Online is required for payroll-only plans is unconfirmed. Intuit must confirm which structure is current.
- ADP RUN: no prices published. W-2 and 1099 forms carry an additional fee with no amount given. Bill Pay and Client Invoicing are described inconsistently across ADP's pages.
- Paychex Flex: no prices published; how add-ons are priced is not explained; the pages reviewed do not map features to the four packages; "Paychex Flex Select" appears on one page but not on the Compare page, so whether it is a current package is unverified.
- Gusto: the pricing page displays a dollar sign without naming the currency. State tax registration is priced separately and varies by state, so confirm the exact registration total for your states with Gusto before you budget.
Cost drivers to model
Total cost depends on headcount, pay frequency, number of states, contractor volume, pay-speed options, support tier and HR, time or benefits add-ons. Gusto, for example, lists add-ons for next-day pay, instant pay, same-day pay, Priority Support and Business Compliance, and charges separately for state tax registration. Its Simple plan covers one state; multi-state payroll requires Plus or Premium. Example for 10 employees, before add-ons and any applicable registration fees: Gusto Simple in one state is $49 plus 10 x $6, or $109 per month; Gusto Plus in more than one state is $200 per month at Plus's published rates. Calculate from the current pricing page for published products and request itemized quotes for quote-based products, including fees for W-2 and 1099 forms, setup, migration and add-ons.
When you are ready, review current plans and pricing on the vendor's website and request a written quote that itemizes every module and fee you need.
Small Business vs. Enterprise
Who Payroll Software and Services Are For
This guide is for US businesses choosing a payroll product, from owner-run businesses with a handful of workers to mid-size employers. It covers products that calculate pay, withhold and file payroll taxes, and issue year-end forms. Several products in this set also sell HR, time tracking and benefits, and one sells a PEO; this guide treats those as add-ons or separate decisions rather than part of the payroll evaluation.
Scope boundaries used in this guide, carried over from the reviews:
- ADP: RUN Powered by ADP only, not ADP Workforce Now.
- Paychex: Paychex Flex payroll only. Paychex PEO, insurance and other products are out of scope.
- QuickBooks Payroll: payroll only. QuickBooks Online accounting is a separate category and is mentioned only where it affects payroll packaging or price.
- Rippling: the payroll module only, not the wider HCM, IT or spend platform.
- Paylocity and Paycom: payroll-first. Broader HCM modules are mentioned only where they affect fit or packaging.
- Justworks: Payroll and PEO are treated as separate purchase models. Employer of Record (EOR) is out of scope.
- Patriot Payroll: Patriot Payroll only, not Patriot Accounting.
Payroll Software versus PEO versus Broader HCM Platform
The Justworks pages reviewed do not explain the PEO co-employment arrangement, and the reviews therefore do not describe how a PEO changes the employer relationship. A first-party help or legal source is needed before making that statement. Justworks' pages describe its PEO as "IRS-certified and ESAC-accredited," a PEO certification claim and not a security attestation.
Do not compare PEO per-employee pricing against payroll-only base-plus-per-person pricing as if they were the same product. Justworks Payroll ($8 per employee per month plus a $50 base fee) and Justworks PEO (priced separately per employee; see vendor pricing) are separate purchase decisions. Before choosing a PEO, a buyer should obtain written explanations of the employment arrangement, liability allocation, benefits and termination terms from the provider and seek legal or tax advice where appropriate.
When to Move to a More Advanced HR or HCM Platform
Based on the scope boundaries in the reviews:
- You are managing HR, time, benefits and payroll in separate tools and the duplicate data entry is costing time. Platform-style products (Rippling, Paycom, Paylocity) are designed to draw payroll from HR data in one system. Rippling's payroll module requires its core platform.
- Your headcount is outgrowing a small-business product. ADP positions RUN for 1 to 49 employees and Workforce Now (not reviewed here) for 50 and over, though ADP does not say RUN is unsuitable above 49. Paylocity names separate small, midsize and enterprise segments. Ask what an upgrade path costs and requires before you buy.
- You need more than payroll tax handling. If you need talent, compliance, finance or IT workflows in the same system, evaluate the broader platform rather than adding point tools to payroll.
- Tradeoffs: broader platforms generally involve sales-led pricing, longer implementation and less price transparency. Paycom states it does not integrate specifically with other providers, although it builds custom converters to import data, so adopting it may mean moving more functions onto its platform.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between payroll software and a PEO? A PEO is a different employment arrangement that bundles payroll with benefits and HR support. Payroll software processes payroll and taxes. Justworks sells both as separate models with different pricing, and its pages reviewed do not explain the PEO co-employment arrangement.
Which payroll products publish their prices? As of the research dates, Gusto, OnPay, Patriot Payroll, Justworks and QuickBooks Payroll publish prices. QuickBooks Payroll's published figures conflict across Intuit pages. ADP RUN, Paychex Flex, Rippling, Paycom and Paylocity do not publish prices.
How is payroll usually priced? Commonly a monthly base fee plus a per-person fee, though some products price per employee only or by quote. Gusto Simple, for example, starts from $49 per month plus $6 per person per month for payroll in one state.
Does payroll software cost more if I pay employees in more than one state? It can. Gusto's Simple plan covers one state, and multi-state payroll requires its Plus or Premium plan, which costs more per month and per person. Registering the business for payroll taxes in a new state can also carry a separate fee, which Gusto prices by state. Ask any vendor how it prices additional states and state registration.
Do payroll providers file taxes for me? Most products in this set state that they calculate and file payroll taxes, but scope differs (for example, local tax handling, additional states and year-end form fees). Read each vendor's scope and guarantee terms, which several reviews flagged as not visible.
Can payroll handle contractors and international workers? Contractor handling and pricing differ by vendor. Justworks lists international contractors (60+ countries) as an add-on; see vendor pricing. Patriot Payroll requires US-located employees. Paychex Flex payroll is primarily designed for US-based employees and contractors.
Do I need QuickBooks Online to use QuickBooks Payroll? Intuit shows payroll-only plans, but no page states explicitly whether a QuickBooks Online subscription is required. Confirm with Intuit.
Is a free trial available? Free trial status is not stated or is unconfirmed for most products in this set. Gusto states none for its base plans. Confirm current trial terms with the vendor.
Which product is most secure? This guide does not name one. Security evidence differs in type, scope and detail (see the “Security and Compliance Evidence” section), and several vendors do not state SOC report types or product scope.
Does this guide rank the products? No. Products are listed in a fixed order and fit guidance is editorial analysis based on stated criteria.
How We Evaluate Payroll Software and Services
We compared ten payroll products on documented pricing and add-on scope, tax filing and multi-state coverage, contractor and international support, time, HR and benefits connections, support, and security or compliance information. Buyer-fit picks reflect company size, pay frequency and administrative capacity; they are not a ranked list. SoBizee did not hands-on test these products. The guide is based on first-party vendor sources, separates documented product information from SoBizee editorial analysis, and treats statements labeled "vendor claim" as not independently verified. Prices, plans and security wording change often, so confirm current details with each vendor before you buy.
SoBizee compared the products on the criteria its research documents: whether prices are published or quote-based, the worker types and states each product covers, tax filing, pay speed and support, HR, time and benefits add-ons, whether a payroll product or a PEO is being sold, and security statements. Statements labeled vendor claim are the vendor's own and were not independently verified by SoBizee. This guide does not rank the products. Prices, promotions and packaging change; confirm current details with each vendor before you buy.
Product order and recommendations reflect editorial judgment about buyer fit, not commercial terms.
Read How We Review for our full evaluation process.